It would be hard to think of a worse idea than casting Melanie Griffith, with her soft-as-down little-girl voice, as a jaded New York homicide cop. Here’s one, though: casting her as a jaded New York homicide cop who goes undercover in the Brooklyn Hasidic community, where she learns that Jews Are People Too. A Stranger Among Us was obviously modeled on another modern thriller about an anachronistic religious sect (can’t you just hear the pitch meeting? — ”It’s Witness with matzoh balls!”). But the director, Sidney Lumet (Serpico, Q&A), fails to work up his usual cop-movie excitement, and the Hasidim aren’t drawn with any emotional complexity. Griffith spends most of the time trying to seduce a sexy young Hasid who is described as being a ”Mozart” of Jewish learning. Sorry, but as played by the placidly appealing Eric Thal, he seems more like the Rob Lowe of Jewish learning. C
Genre: Romance, Mystery and Thriller, Drama; Starring: Eric Thal, Melanie Griffith, James Gandolfini, Mia Sara, Jamey Sheridan; Director: Sidney Lumet; Author: Robert J. Avrech; Runtime (in minutes): 110; MPAA Rating: PG-13; Distributor: Buena Vista Pictures
Posted July 24 1992 — 12:00 AM EDT
- Lady Gaga crashes James Corden's monologue
- What to Watch Wednesday: 'Rectify' enters its final season
- Carpool Karaoke: Lady Gaga sings, James Corden wears meat dress
- 'Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.': Is Philinda finally going to happen?
- Adele endorses Hillary Clinton at Miami concert
- Stephen Colbert compares Donald Trump to Voldemort
- 'This Is Us': Dan Fogelman breaks down Jack and William revelations
- 'The Walking Dead': Exclusive Season Premiere Storyboards
- 'Gilmore Girls' Trailer: A Deep Dive Into the Return to Stars Hollow
- 15 Ultimate Halloween Movie Picks, From Horror-Loving Actors and Filmmakers
- This Is What the 2001 CMAs Looked Like
- 'Smallville': Where Are They Now?
- Flashback to Taylor Swift's First Album Drop