The Comancheros | EW.com

video

The ComancherosJohn Wayne didn't live to see laserdisc become the video format of choice for movie buffs and filmmakers, but somebody somewhere thinks he should have....The ComancherosWesternUnratedJohn Wayne didn't live to see laserdisc become the video format of choice for movie buffs and filmmakers, but somebody somewhere thinks he should have....1994-02-04Jack ElamLee MarvinJack Elam, Lee Marvin
C+

The Comancheros

Genre: Western; Starring: Stuart Whitman, John Wayne, Jack Elam, Lee Marvin; Director: Michael Curtiz; Author: James Edward Grant; Status: In Season; MPAA Rating: Unrated

John Wayne didn’t live to see laserdisc become the video format of choice for movie buffs and filmmakers, but somebody somewhere thinks he should have. That’s one conclusion to be drawn from this idolatrous edition of The Comancheros, a middling good-guys-versus-faux-Indians Western. Sure, the transfer is gorgeous, as is the restored stereo soundtrack; sure, the bonuses — commentary by surviving actors, production stills — are agreeable time-wasters. But The Comancheros remains a standard shoot-‘em-up, notable only as the last work of Casablanca director Michael Curtiz. As a result, the treatment here seems so overblown it diminishes the movie’s modest pleasures. C+

More from Our Partners