Owen Gleiberman
January 28, 2000 AT 05:00 AM EST

Down to You

type
Movie
Current Status
In Season
mpaa
PG-13
runtime
89 minutes
performer
Freddie Prinze Jr., Julia Stiles, Ashton Kutcher
director
Kris Isacsson
genre
Romance

We gave it a F

If I could call a moratorium on anything in movies, I think it would be all of those scenes in which a boho, white, middle-class, teenage romantic lip-synchs to a song by a black pop star, all to demonstrate that he is very down with his bad self. The granddaddy of these hit-parade grotesqueries is, of course, Jon Cryer’s scrunchy-eyed rendition of Otis Redding’s ”Try a Little Tenderness” in ”Pretty in Pink.” Nothing in the abysmal youth-market comedy Down to You is quite that unspeakable, but the film does include two lip-synch specials that are worthy of a cringe.

In the first, Julia Stiles, as a college artiste spilling over with love for her new fella (Freddie Prinze Jr., from ”She’s All That”), announces that ”a little soul is necessary in life,” and she then mimes and shimmies to a recording of Al Green’s ”Let’s Stay Together,” looking all the while like the shiest girl in a lap-dance competition. Later, Prinze, holding up a spoon like a microphone (how fun-kay!), does similar damage to Barry White’s ”Can’t Get Enough of Your Love, Babe.” If there’s anything you can say with certainty about the two agonizingly earnest lovers of ”Down to You,” it’s that they truly deserve one another.

Prinze and Stiles spend the entire movie staring moistly at each other — that is, when they aren’t delivering dialogue that’s embarrassing in its coy and wistful hungry-heart neuroticism. Prinze, in particular, looks as if he’d spent the last five hours trying to muster a smile for a photograph he wished would just get taken already. Stiles, who was charming in her snappishness in ”10 Things I Hate About You,” here plays a self-serious freshman princess with so much precious conviction that you want to send her to a beer bash before she looks into the camera and confesses again.

At one point the two have a spat and apologize, and Prinze observes: ”That’s when the making up feels best. And you know what comes next? The tingles!” The tingles? Actually, a line like that gives me the heebie-jeebies, and ”Down to You” is stuffed with them. Making his first feature, writer-director Kris Isacsson treats the most squishy-sincere rituals of first love with a quivering sense of discovery. Obviously, it’s a discovery to him. For the audience, it’s like watching the dreckiest of teen puppy courtships trying to pass itself off as ”Annie Hall.” La-de-blah.

You May Like

Comments

EDIT POST