EW Staff
March 15, 2004 AT 05:00 AM EST

Diana DeGarmo’s pros and cons

AGE 16

HOMETOWN Snellville, Ga.

FINALS-QUALIFYING SONG ”I’ve Got the Music in Me”

SHE SAYS [After judges told her not to wear pink] ”I’m not giving up on pink!”

PRO She’s cute as a button…

CON …but on the verge of being so cutesy-poo we can’t stand it.

EARLY WORD FROM SIMON ET AL. Despite their problems with her pink-and-black outfits, Simon cooed that she reminded him of Christina Aguilera — ”when she was nice.”

WE SAY As long as she doesn’t sing ”Good Ship Lollipop,” she can hang around…for a few weeks.

You May Like