John Stevens' pros and cons | EW.com

TV

John Stevens' pros and cons

John Stevens

John Stevens’ pros and cons

AGE 16

HOMETOWN East Amherst, N.Y.

FINALS-QUALIFYING SONG ”She’s Always a Woman”

HE SAYS ”I’ve been told many times before this that I need to express myself more, so I’m trying to be more expressive in everything I do.”

PRO He’s a throwback to smooth crooners past…

CON …but do we really need a newbie Sinatra with a strong resemblence to Conan O’Brien?

EARLY WORD FROM SIMON ET AL. Randy and Paula have been disappointed in Stevens’ low energy.

WE SAY Barring a Clay Aiken-esque makeover, his old-timey style is too offbeat to win.

More from Our Partners