Which ''I Love Lucy'' set is best? | EW.com

Movies

Which ''I Love Lucy'' set is best?

Which ”I Love Lucy” set is best?

Which chapters of TV comedy?s Bible According to Lucy do you live by? The Gospels: all 31 episodes of the original show?s season 2, including the candy factory and the birth of Little Ricky? Or Revelations: 24 ”best-loved” episodes of her fourth series, Here?s Lucy, handpicked by children/costars Lucie Arnaz and Desi Arnaz Jr., remastered in eye-poking color, stuffed with cameos by the likes of Elizabeth Taylor (that?s Liz?s real Krupp diamond, not a prop, stuck on Lucy?s hand), and a lot funnier than you remember? On novelty value alone, we say the latter; in fact, we have a whole new appreciation for the oeuvre of Gale Gordon.

EXTRAS
The Paramount box has trivia, flubs, original openers and closers, and episodes of Ball?s late-?40s radio show, but the Shout! set digs deeper: rehearsal footage, commentary by not only Lucie and Desi Jr. but guests like Carol Burnett and Wayne Newton, and rare tape of Ball?s producer/second husband Gary Morton warming up the crowd. Rare for good reason: He was terrible. ”I Love Lucy”: A- ”Here?s Lucy”: A

More from Our Partners