Law and Order: Trial by Jury: Virginia Sherwood
Gillian Flynn
April 15, 2005 AT 04:00 AM EDT

Law & Order: Trial by Jury

TV Show
Current Status
In Season
Amy Carlson, Bebe Neuwirth, Kirk Acevedo, Scott Cohen
Crime, Drama

We gave it a B-

Law & Order: Trial by Jury isn’t bad. It’s just not necessary. Set during the trial of a crime, the series follows the strategies of Assistant DA Tracey Kibre (Cheers‘ Bebe Neuwirth, who plays Kibre like Lilith dipped in cinnamon). It also dives into the (usually ugly) schemes of the defense attorneys, played by rotating guest stars like Annabella Sciorra.

Trial has the reliable rhythms of any Law & Order — even its twists feel familiar. Worse, there’s no drama to be wrung from Kibre’s legal wrangling: As the good guy, she never gets dirty. Instead, Trial finds villains in wildly guilty defendants, unbelievably prejudiced judges, and seriously nasty defense attorneys (Lorraine Bracco played a lawyer who actually drove her vigilante client to the murder scene — a silly story that was, admittedly, pretty fun). In the end, though, Trial never justifies its existence as the fourth member of the crowded franchise. In legal jargon: It’s a nuisance suit.

You May Like