Reviewing the Reviews: 'Chronicles of Narnia' |

News | PopWatch

Reviewing the Reviews: 'Chronicles of Narnia'


94339__narnia_lThe Chronicles of Narnia: The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe proved especially tricky to this weekend’s headline writers. Most reviewers had a hard time coming up with a good pun on the movie’s cumbersome title; better to reference the plot, with its magical closet portal to a fantasy world of perpetual winter, and its allegorical Christ-figure hero, the talking lion Aslan. Many critics noted the C.S. Lewis adaptation’s resemblance to another recent fantasy-epic franchise, one based on the books of Lewis’ pal J.R.R. Tolkien. (Full disclosure: I reviewed the movie this week for the Boston Phoenix, so I’m partial to the headline I wrote.) But there were a couple other reviews (in the Village Voice and the New York Post) whose headlines were even funnier. Read on and see if I’m lion.

‘Lion’ Kings:
New York Newsday: In with a roar, out with a yawn
East Valley (Ariz.) Tribune: ‘Narnia’ could use sharper teeth

Chill out:
Las Vegas Weekly: Winter Wonderland
Dallas Observer: Lion in Winter
Fort Worth Star-Telegram: Cold case

Allegory details:
Arizona Daily Star: An epic of biblical proportion
St. Paul Pioneer Press: Laying down the awe
Calgary Sun: ‘Narnia’ can’t myth
The Stranger (Seattle): Lionizing Jesus
The Hook (Charlottesville, Va.): Narnia 1: The passion of the lion

Hanging in the closet:
USA Today: ‘Narnia’ opens the door to excitement
New York Post: Wardrobe Malfunction
Boston Phoenix: Knights in armoire

Which other fanciful epic does this remind you of?
La Cañada (Calif.) Valley Sun: Lord of the Rings with a Lion
L.A. Weekly: Lions and Witches and Wardrobes – Oh My!
Village Voice: Trapped in the Closet: Robust Rendering of a Fantasy Classic

More from Our Partners