Top Chef | EW.com

TV

Top ChefUnlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox's Hell's KitchenTop ChefReality TVUnlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox's Hell's Kitchen2007-08-06

(Carin Baer)

A-

Top Chef

Genre: Reality TV; Lead Performer: Tom Colicchio, Padma Lakshmi, Gail Simmons; Broadcaster: Bravo; Status: On Hiatus; Seasons: 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12

Unlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox’s Hell's Kitchen, on season 3 of Top Chef the food always looks mouthwatering; Judge Tom Colicchio is an exemplary combination of talent, constructiveness, and high standards; and not a morsel of entertainment value is wasted. Like most Bravo competition shows, Top Chef proceeds from the premise that there is fun in putting a group of exceptionally skilled and ambitious people together and pushing them to do their best. It might not sound like much fun to eavesdrop on a bunch of talented prima donnas throwing down over sloppy knife work and the deployment of flavored foams, but it’s much more exciting (and appetite-whetting) than the Hell’s Kitchen alternative of watching a bunch of doofuses get reamed for burning the rice. The food looks better on Top Chef, and so does the production; there isn’t nearly as much TV-for-dummies editing as on Hell’s Kitchen — you know, in case your mind wandered during the commercial, here’s a whole minute that you just saw again. That’s filler — TV’s version of Hamburger Helper. And real cooking shows don’t use it. In my dream reality series, the best of Top Chef’s contestants would go burner to burner with Ramsay. I suspect they’d make sushi out of him. And still make it look good enough to eat. A-

More from Our Partners