Who's missing from our list of best 'American Idol' auditions? | EW.com

News | PopWatch

Who's missing from our list of best 'American Idol' auditions?

Idol_lOh yeah. I just threw down – threw down my list of the 12 Best American Idol Auditions of All Time, that is. (Click here to read it.) You’ll note there are some controversial choices (including a couple of contestants who never even made the finals) and some big-name omissions (sorry, not every champ made the best first impression). Either way, though, I figured all you Idol junkies would want a forum to discuss your own Top 12 lists, and to unleash your inner Simons (or Paulas) regarding my selection. Let the fun and debating begin in the comments section below!

UPDATE: Technical issues with the gallery have been resolved. Click through the whole thing, then come back here and throw down.

More from Our Partners