How did Carly Smithson land in the bottom three on 'Idol'? | EW.com

News | PopWatch

How did Carly Smithson land in the bottom three on 'Idol'?

Our viewer call-in guest has a theory! Plus, Kristen Baldwin, Dalton Ross, and I talk about the contestants who dodged bullets by cracking Idol’s season 7 top 10. (Hint: Their initials are R.M. and M.J.)