2008 may already seem like forever ago. Twenty-one days? That’s, like, a decade in Twitter time! But the year in music isn’t truly over ‘til the results of the Village Voice’s Pazz & Jop critics’ poll are out. In developments that should shock absolutely no one, the Voice announced today that TV on the Radio’s Dear Science won the albums race, while critics voted M.I.A.’s “Paper Planes” the top single – both excellent choices. (Yes, technically “Paper Planes” came out in 2007, but the Pineapple Express trailer made it a major ‘08 jam, and that’s good enough for P&J rules.)
In terms of sales, 2008 was either Lil Wayne’s or Taylor Swift’s year, depending how you count. But of course sales don’t mean much to many of the music writers who vote in P&J. Weezy, who managed a respectable No. 6 on the albums poll and No. 5 on the singles poll (“A Milli”), might have been undermined by the sheer volume of music heput out last year – he’s listed on no less than 21 ranking singles, all the way down to No. 1645 (Keri Hilson’s “Turnin’ Me On”). No such luck for Taylor Swift, who was relegated to the No. 58 album and No. 49 single.
My own Pazz & Jop ‘08 ballot is here; EW’s Rob Brunner, Jason Adams, and Whitney Pastorek all submitted ballots, too. I know I’d probably tweak the order of mine in a few places if I were assembling it again today, but hey, a deadline’s a deadline, and these ballots were due on Christmas Eve. And while the final P&J results may be closed, the endless debate and dissection is only beginning. So what do you think of our individual picks and the overall Pazz & Jop winners? Have at it!
More on the music of 2008:
The Best and Worst Albums of 2008: Leah Greenblatt’s picks
The Best and Worst Albums of 2008: Chris Willman’s picks
The Best Albums of 2008: Stephen King’s picks
2008’s best music quotes