Dave Karger
June 03, 2009 AT 11:55 PM EDT

According to Variety, Jack Nicholson is in talks to join James L. Brooks’ upcoming untitled romantic comedy starring Reese Witherspoon, Paul Rudd, and Owen Wilson. Nicholson would play Rudd’s father, a role that Bill Murray was initially considering but has apparently abandoned.

If you ask me, Nicholson and Murray are both ridiculously cool choices to be anyone’s dad. But which of the two more resembles Rudd? Take a look at these photos and judge for yourself.

addCredit(“Nicholson: Solarpix/PR Photos ; Rudd: David Gabber/PR Photos; Murray: Hubert Boesl/Landov”)

You May Like