Adam B. Vary
May 05, 2011 AT 07:00 PM EDT

The consensus around PopWatch HQ is that Jacob Lusk’s wildly off-pitch, oddly hip-thrusting performance of the Jordin Sparks/Chris Brown duet “No Air” is easily the gospel diva’s worst ever on the show, and possibly one of the worst of the season period. Which is to say, if he doesn’t go home tonight, Lusk will rank alongside Nikki McKibbin and Jasmine Trias as one of the most tenacious how-has-this-person-stuck-around-this-long Idol contestants ever. (Those words are not easy for me to write, either — many of you will recall my defense of the Lusky Stank five weeks ago, back when his could-not-be-more-perfect performance of “You’re All I Need To Get By” was still ringing in my head. Sigh. Those were the days.)

Should Jacob pull off another narrow escape, who else is in the danger zone this week? Hopefully not Haley, whose “The House of the Rising Sun” was easily her best performance to date (and of the season period). Could Lauren (who was perfectly fine), James (who was emotionally raw and vocally shaky), and Scotty (who turned it up to 11 for his first song, and down to snoozeville for his second) finally find themselves officially sitting on a silver stool of doom?

Vote in the polls below on who you think will be in the bottom two this week, and who is going home, and then defend your choices in the comments!

// Take Our Poll
// Take Our Poll

Follow Adam on Twitter

Read more on American Idol:

‘American Idol’ recap: In It to Spin It

‘American Idol’ on the scene for Top 5 performance night: The details on Jennifer Lopez’s hot-hot-hot (and hidden) heels!

‘American Idol’ behind the scenes: ‘Idol’ coaches talk the Top 5 — EXCLUSIVE

What’s the judges’ beef with ‘Idol’ contestant Haley?

You May Like