October 29, 2011 at 06:15 PM EDT

Since the start of the fall TV season, only two shows have been tops with EW.com readers: The Vampire Diaries and Breaking Bad. To that storied list we can now add NBC’s wily and weird Thursday night cult comedy Community, which tickled and (perhaps) terrified viewers with a Halloween anthology episode. Meanwhile, Once Upon a Time‘s series premiere landed just out of the top five. Check out the complete rankings below: 

1. Community (NBC) — last week: not ranked

2. Revenge (ABC) — last week: 3

3. Happy Endings (ABC) — last week: 4

4. American Horror Story (FX) — last week: not ranked

5. The Good Wife (CBS) — last week: not ranked

Honorable mentions: Once Upon a Time; The Vampire Diaries; Parks and Recreation; The Walking Dead; Survivor: South Pacific

Unhappy with the winners? Then check out EW’s recaps each week, and make sure to rate that week’s episode!

Read more:

TV LEADERBOARD WEEK 5: ‘The Vampire Diaries’ takes the lead again

TV LEADERBOARD WEEK 4: ‘Breaking Bad’ goes out on top of EW.com reader ratings

TV LEADERBOARD WEEK 3: ‘Breaking Bad’ tops EW.com reader ratings

You May Like