Girl Land review - Caitlin Flanagan | EW.com

Books

Girl Land

Girl LandEver nostalgic for things that never were, the conservative social critic Caitlin Flanagan identifies a stretch between girlhood and womanhood as a...Girl LandEssaysEver nostalgic for things that never were, the conservative social critic Caitlin Flanagan identifies a stretch between girlhood and womanhood as a...2012-01-11Reagan Arthur Books
NOT SO SAGE ADVICE Flanagan's work, describing the time between girlhood and womanhood, proves less than effective

NOT SO SAGE ADVICE Flanagan's work, describing the time between girlhood and womanhood, proves less than effective

C+

Girl Land

Genre: Essays; Author: Caitlin Flanagan; Publisher: Reagan Arthur Books

Ever nostalgic for things that never were, the conservative social critic Caitlin Flanagan identifies a stretch between girlhood and womanhood as a developmental chrysalis she calls ”Girl Land.” Using her own cushioned upbringing to muse about momentous events including proms, dating, and diaries, she lobs a few toothless provocations, e.g., ”The mass media in which so many girls are immersed today does not mean them well.” Then she comes up with an equally toothless solution to all that threatens Girl Land: Keep Internet access out of girls’ bedrooms! That’s it? Yep, that’s it. C+