Timothy A Clary/AFP/Getty Images
Mandi Bierly
February 06, 2012 AT 06:29 PM EST

The debate continues this morning over Madonna’s Super Bowl halftime performance: Was it, as EW’s Ken Tucker says, joyous, unironic, and openhearted, or, as The Vampire Diaries‘ star Paul Wesley succinctly put it on Twitter, “one of the most unintentionally amusing things” you’ve seen in a long while? Either way, it’s a performance you’ll remember (and not just for M.I.A.’s middle finger). Let’s find out where Madonna ranks among the halftime headliners in recent memory: 

//static.polldaddy.com/p/5915779.js Take Our Poll
//static.polldaddy.com/p/5915837.js Take Our Poll

Read more:

Madonna at the Super Bowl review: A shockingly sincere, joyous performance

M.I.A. flips middle finger during Super Bowl halftime show — PHOTO

Parents group slams M.I.A.’s Super Bowl flip off: ‘The NFL lied’

Super Bowl 2012: Best and Worst Commercials

You May Like