EW Staff
July 04, 2012 AT 02:17 PM EDT

Just 10 years after Tobey Maguire donned the Spidey suit for the first time, we have a reboot of the franchise in The Amazing Spider-Man, with Andrew Garfield in the titular role. EW movie critic Lisa Schwarzbaum calls Garfield a “brilliant substitute and replacement” for Maguire but fellow critic Owen Gleiberman thinks the movie is “un-amazing.” Watch their full discussion below!


Movie Talk with Owen and Lisa: ‘Magic Mike’ is a ‘guilt-free stripper movie’ — VIDEO

Movie Talk With Owen and Lisa: Does ‘Rock of Ages’ deliver? VIDEO

You May Like