Tim Stack
October 05, 2012 AT 06:04 PM EDT

Warner Bros. Entertainment; Anthony Harvey/Getty

Avert your eyes if you  haven’t watched last night’s Glee…but for those who have you’re probably wondering, Who the hell is this Eli guy that Blaine cheated with?!?!?! Seen only in text messages, Eli is the mystery man whom Blaine admitted to Kurt about being with and caused the much-loved Glee gays to break-up.

Now, EW has learned that are no immediate plans to introduce Eli in the coming episodes. But we figure why not brainstorm who should play this troublemaker? It may be that I’ve seen too many Pitch Perfect trailers as of late, but I think Skylar Astin, who plays Anna Kendrick’s love interest in the acapella flick, might be a good choice. He’s cute and he can sing. Plus, he’s a Spring Awakening alum and would reunite him with his former castmates Lea Michele, Jenna Ushkowitz, and Jonathan Groff.

What do you think Gleeks? Who should play Eli?

Read more:

‘Glee’ recap: The Break-Up

‘Glee’ scoop: Details on tonight’s pivotal, emotional, and epic ‘Break-Up’ episode

‘Glee’ recap: Rabbit Feet and Makeovers

Follow Tim on Twitter: @EWTimStack

You May Like