Toby's Room - review - Pat Barker | EW.com

Books

Toby's Room

Toby's RoomEven after her acclaimed Regeneration trilogy, Barker is still fixated on WWI-era England. Her new novel Toby's Room is both a...Toby's RoomFictionEven after her acclaimed Regeneration trilogy, Barker is still fixated on WWI-era England. Her new novel Toby's Room is both a...2012-10-05Doubleday
LOVE TRIANGLE Although Barker's writing is clear, his narrative is dreary

LOVE TRIANGLE Although Barker's writing is clear, his narrative is dreary

B-

Toby's Room

Genre: Fiction; Author: Pat Barker; Status: In Season; Publisher: Doubleday

Even after her acclaimed Regeneration trilogy, Barker is still fixated on WWI-era England. Her new novel Toby’s Room is both a prequel and a sequel to 2007’s Life Class, about a trio of aspiring painters in 1914 London. Elinor Brooke, the center of Life Class’ love triangle, is preoccupied with her superclose older brother, Toby, who’s declared ”missing, believed killed” while serving in Ypres with Kit, one of her art-school suitors. Though the writing is lucid and often beautiful, the narrative tends to dither, and the final reveal delivers only a muted impact. B-

Originally posted October 5 2012 — 12:00 AM EDT

More from Our Partners