Jonathan Mannion/The CW; John Russo/NBC
EW Staff
June 14, 2013 AT 08:30 PM EDT

There were easy victories — Shakira trounced Aguilera —  and there were upsets — RuPaul triumphed over JLo — during round 1 of our Reality TV Judge Fashion Face-Off. Now on to round 2!

Who deserves the title of “Best Dressed Reality TV Judge” and who should be sent packing? Check out our full bracket here and vote in the polls below to determine who will move on to the Final Four. 

Mariah Carey (American Idol) vs. Shakira (The Voice)

// Take Our Poll

Padma Lakshmi (Top Chef) vs. Heidi Klum (Project Runway)

// Take Our Poll

RuPaul (RuPaul’s Drag Race) vs. Demi Lovato (X Factor)

// Take Our Poll

Nicole Richie (Fashion Star) vs. Tyra Banks (America’s Next Top Model)

// Take Our Poll

The Best Dressed Reality TV Judge Tournament:

Round 1, part 1

Round 1, part 2

You May Like