Samantha Highfill
January 07, 2014 AT 07:08 PM EST

By the end of the Pretty Little Liars‘ Halloween episode, the secret was revealed: Alison DiLaurentis is alive! But what does that mean for the Liars when the show returns for season 4B? According to Keegan Allen, it means the girls are just about at the end of their ropes. “Each one of the girls are starting to break down,” Allen said. “After all this time, they should’ve broken down the first week. They’re all trying to get a grip on it and they’re falling apart, each one of them separately. Spencer more than others. She kind of loses it, but in a way that you never saw coming.”

However, unlike last season, Toby isn’t the cause of Spencer’s breakdown this time. “I don’t think it has to do with Toby. Toby is trying to deal with all of the stuff going on with Spencer, but he’s also trying to figure it out because he does know. The guys know now. It’s about Toby being there for Spencer in her time of despair. She kind of loses her mind again but not in the way that you think,” Allen said.

So while we wait to find out what it is that causes Spencer’s second mental collapse of the series, we put the man who plays her on-screen boyfriend Toby Cavanaugh in the hot seat for our Pop Culture Personality Test. From his teenage style icons to his favorite TV show growing up, watch where Allen ranks in our test below:

Pretty Little Liars returns Tuesday night at 8 p.m. on ABC Family.

You May Like