James Hibberd
January 15, 2014 AT 04:11 PM EST

What does Brooklyn Nine-Nine need to do to grow its ratings?

The acclaimed freshman Fox comedy actually went down Tuesday night. Down — after star Andy Samberg won the Golden Globe for best actor in a comedy and the show itself won best comedy series Sunday night. Brooklyn didn’t dip much, just a mere tenth of a point in the preliminary 18-49 ratings (and that could be erased by the time the afternoon nationals are released) and the comedy was up a hair in total viewers. But with ratings for the show already at a super modest level, one would hope to see a notable increased interest after all that publicity for a new-ish show — the Globes were watched by 21 million viewers. Brooklyn had just 3.5 million viewers and a 1.4 in the adult demo. Then New Girl was steady and Mindy Project was down a tenth. You can partly blame DadsBrooklyn‘s lead-in that kicked off Fox’s lineup at 8 p.m. was down 20 percent. And who doesn’t want to blame Dads for something?

We’ve seen this before. Fox’s Arrested Development was praised by every critic and won every award under the sun (practically) and still couldn’t ultimately muster a long-term survivable rating.

Over on The CW, the return of The Originals didn’t see a bump out if its fight with ABC Family’s Pretty Little Liars (but it made for fun social media fodder), and Supernatural was down a tenth too.

ABC’s lineup was mostly steady, though new drama Killer Women went down 22 percent from its already DOA premiere. CBS’ drama block was perfectly flat. NBC’s Biggest Loser was unchanged, though Chicago Fire dropped 10 percent. Full chart:

FOX 8:00P DADS- 1.2 3,179
8:30P BRKLYN 9-9- 1.4 3,524
9:00P NEW GIRL- 1.6 3,275
9:30P MNDY PRJCT- 1.2 2,538
ABC 8-9P MARVL-SHLD- 2.2 6,254
9:00P GOLDBERGS- 1.8 4,895
9:30P TROPHY WIF- 1.1 3,497
10-11P KILLER WMN- 0.7 3,465
CBS 8-9P NCIS- 3.0 19,453
9-10P NCIS:LA- 2.4 15,874
10-11P PERSON-INT- 2.0 12,349
NBC 8-10P BIGST LR15- 1.7 5,508
10-11P CHCGO FIRE- 1.8 6,612
CW 8-9P ORIGINALS- 0.9 1,981
9-10P SUPRNATURAL- 1.0 2,259


You May Like