James Hibberd
May 28, 2014 AT 04:51 PM EDT

NBC’s America’s Got Talent managed to do what many other reality shows can’t pull off: Return to the air with nearly the exact same rating as last year.

The two-hour AGT debut Tuesday night had 11.9 million viewers and a 3.0 rating among adults 18-49, just off a tenth from last year’s premiere in early June. This is the talent competition’s lowest-rated premiere yet — but that’s pretty much to be expected, given the show has been around for nine seasons. Lead-out The Night Shift had the network’s best rating for a summer drama premiere in nearly five years.

Another nearly brand new reality show had a very different fate: Fox’s I Wanna Marry Harry dove 43 percent from last week’s abysmal premiere to tie a repeat of The CW’s Supernatural in the demo for the hour. Last week Harry had an American Idol lead-in, though. Full chart:

NET/TIME/SHOW  18-49 rating total viewers (+000)
FOX 8-9P RIOT- 0.6 1,387
9-10P I WNNA-HRY- 0.4 1,200
ABC 8-10P EXT WT LSS- P 1.3 3,871
10-11P CELEB-SWAP- 1.2 3,735
CBS 8-9P NCIS- R 1.2 9,280
9-10P NCIS:LA- R 1.1 7,843
10-11P PERSON-INT- R 0.8 5,317
NBC 8-10P AM-TLNT-TU- P 3.0 11,911
10-11P NIGHT SHFT- P 1.6 7,782
CW 8-9P ORIGINALS- R 0.3 948
9-10P SUPRNATURAL- R 0.4 1,061

You May Like