Samantha Highfill
September 09, 2014 AT 03:54 PM EDT

The story of Faking It started with one lie: Best friends Amy and Karma decided to pretend to be a couple so that they could be “cool.” But one lie turned into many more when Amy realized she had real feelings for Karma, was rejected by her bestie, and then slept with Karma’s boyfriend. But as the season-two trailer puts it, “What does it all mean?”

Well, for now, it looks like it means keeping secrets, acting normal, and eventually, everything blowing up in a dramatic fashion.

Faking It kicks off its second season Tuesday, Sept. 23 at 10:30 p.m. on MTV.

You May Like