Cue up your favorite Liam Neesons movie and limber up those hands for a game of slap ass: Key & Peele will kick off season four tonight. To mark the occasion—and to tip our silliest of silly hats to this ridiculously clever and inventive sketch series—we tapped the two stars, Keegan-Michael Key and Jordan Peele, to serve as guest editors of this week’s issue of Entertainment Weekly. Not surprisingly, they showcased a whole new set of skills. But given that we can never get enough of their impressions, we also asked them to whip out their best impersonations of each other. And not only do you get to enjoy this freakiest of Fridays swap on a Wednesday, you get to vote for who nails the other one better. Key has a word of warning before making your selection, though. He urges you to choose “not which impression is the most entertaining, but which impression is the most accurate.” Watch the video and then vote with your conscience. Or your computer.
For more, check out Key and Peele’s issue of Entertainment Weekly, on newsstands Friday.