Esther Zuckerman
January 20, 2015 AT 02:52 PM EST

Abbi Jacobson and Ilana Glazer of Broad City brought out their finest—no, their dumbest—for an appearance on Jimmy Kimmel Live Monday night. The ladies explained that they initially splurged on dresses for the show. But as Jacobson said, because they had never done “like an LA, late night show,” they decided to alter their plans. The duo ended up wearing tuxes and top hats à la Dumb and Dumber

“We had never worked with a stylist before,” Jacobson explained. “We want like, old Hollywood charm,” Glazer said, adding scare quotes on “charm.” Kimmel was impressed: “Whatever thinking led to this you really scored here in a big way.”

Elsewhere on his show, Kimmel got Benedict Cumberbatch to test a few different names, including “Groot.”

You May Like