Kelly Connolly
May 08, 2015 AT 04:02 PM EDT

America’s favorite Gemini vegetarian is back.

Reese Witherspoon stepped back into Elle Woods’ so-not-last-season Prada shoes during a visit to Watch What Happens Live on Thursday. With the help of host Andy Cohen, Witherspoon and her Hot Pursuit costar Sofia Vergara recreated Legally Blonde‘s “road trip!” scene, complete with an LSAT book for Witherspoon and a wig for Cohen.

“Her commitment to character is really astounding,” Witherspoon says of Vergara, who begins the scene with an attempted American accent before going back to her Colombian roots. Her costar isn’t so complimentary. 

“Reese, you were a better actress before,” Vergara says.

You May Like