Jack Plunkett
Christopher Rosen
June 07, 2015 AT 01:43 PM EDT

Debate over who was Rory’s best boyfriend on Gilmore Girls has raged for years, but the argument may have finally been decided on Saturday night. During the Gilmore Girls reunion panel at the ATX Festival in Austin, Texas, Rory’s three major significant others — Matt Czuchry (Logan), Jared Padalecki (Dean) and Milo Ventimiglia (Jess) — all named who they felt deserved the younger Gilmore girl’s love.

Ventimiglia: “Team Dean.”

Padalecki: “Team Jess.” (said Ventimiglia: “Logan was a dick.”)

Czuchry: “Team Jess.”

But while Team Jess was the unofficial winner, it was perhaps Gilmore Girls co-star Scott Patterson, who said it best. “None of you are good enough for Rory.”

For more from the Entertainment Weekly-sponsored event, read our full recap here.

You May Like