ABC Family
Samantha Highfill
October 08, 2015 AT 09:35 PM EDT

Well, Pretty Little Liars fans, gone are the days of Charles — we think — and with them are the days of watching Lucy Hale’s slightly off-center finger shush us during the show’s opening. 

Now that the show is jumping forward five years, it’s getting a new opening. E! Online has a first look at the opening, which adds Ali into the mix and switches the shushing duties from Hale to Shay Mitchell. So let’s hear it: Who does it better?

Pretty Little Liars is set to return in 2016.

You May Like