Lloyd Bishop/NBC
Ian Goldstein
October 16, 2015 AT 01:39 PM EDT

This Halloween, some of us will have to admit we’re too old for the typical scary stories. Seth Meyers and Zooey Deschanel tried to remedy this feeling by telling “Adult Scary Stories” on Thursday night’s episode of Late Night.

These nightmares didn’t involve ghosts, ghouls, or goblins; they included plumbers, bands, and babies.

The Rock the Kasbah star told a spooky story about “a beautiful woman with dark brown hair and bright blue eyes” who heard horrifying sounds that made her do something she never thought she would do: call a plumber. The most frightening part? “The actual cost would be higher than the estimate.”

WANT MORE? Keep up with all the latest late-night coverage by subscribing to our newsletter. Head here for more details.

Watch the clip below to see Meyers and Deschanel tell their frightening adult stories. They do the sound effects too.

You May Like