Samantha Highfill
March 22, 2016 AT 06:37 PM EDT

Jared Padalecki and Milo Ventimiglia are no stangers to epic battles between men. Sure, Batman v Superman might involve crazy fight scenes and saving the world and whatnot, but once upon a time, those two fought it out as Dean Forester and Jess Mariano in the equally epic battle of winning Rory Gilmore’s heart. 

And now, Warner Bros. has put together a number of promotional videos for the upcoming Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice, in which they ask various casts to pick a winner. Most recently, they filmed Padalecki and Ventimiglia on the set of Netflix’s Gilmore Girls revival, where both men are reprising their roles. Not surprisingly, Ventimiglia sided with the slightly darker caped crusader, while Padalecki went with the bulletproof hero. (We hear Batman has a thing for Holden Caulfield, too.)

[facebook url="" /]


RELATED: Gilmore Girls: Then and Now

But what we really want to know is: Would Batman be Team Jess? And would Superman be Team Dean?

You May Like