The men of Baby Daddy fighting over a woman is nothing new. In fact, there probably hasn’t been one episode of the Freeform show where Danny, Ben, or Tucker haven’t argued about something related to their romantic prospects.
But on Wednesday’s episode a fight between Tucker and Ben for dibs on a women named Giselle leads to something more: Tucker’s secret.
As seen in the exclusive clip above, Tucker reveals that he knows Giselle (played by Catherine Toribio, who portrays young Xiomara on Jane the Virgin) from his visits to a sperm bank. Which leads us to question: Could there be more than one baby daddy on Baby Daddy!?
Baby Daddy airs Wednesdays at 8:30 p.m. ET on Freeform.