Christian Holub
June 15, 2016 AT 11:32 AM EDT

Jimmy Fallon brought Box of Lies back on Tuesday night for Lena Dunham’s appearance on The Tonight Show. The night before, he had invented a new game of Slip N’ Flip with Liam Hemsworth; Box of Lies, by contrast, is now a storied part of Fallon’s tenure, and Tuesday’s edition reminded viewers why. It’s just so weird.

Dunham went first and opened a box full of pictures of Leonardo DiCaprio labeled “Frances McDormand.” It was so random that Dunham didn’t really know what to do; she decided to try out-weirding it by telling Fallon she actually got a banana dressed up with Sideshow Bob hair and googly eyes, but her over-enthusiasm helped Fallon see right through her. 

Next was Fallon’s turn, and he got a cauldron full of rubber ducks. He tried passing it off as a Barbie Hot Tub. It took little time for Dunham to debunk that. “As if you could recognize a Barbie Hot Tub,” Dunham said. 

“I probably could, I have two little girls!” Fallon said.

Dunham’s second box, the final tiebreaker round, was so weird it put the others to shame: a book of Grimm’s Fairy Tales with the interior pages carved out, The Shawshank Redemption style, to hold a bottle of whiskey. For this last round, Dunham finally changed her strategy. She told the truth, and fooled Fallon. Truth is ever stranger than fiction. 

Watch the clip below.

You May Like