Project Greenlight Art schmart. Ben Affleck and Matt Damon have twice convinced Miramax to pony up several million so that amateurs can create their first indie movie… Project Greenlight Art schmart. Ben Affleck and Matt Damon have twice convinced Miramax to pony up several million so that amateurs can create their first indie movie… 2001-12-02 2005-03-15 2003-06-22 Reality TV Erica Beeney Marcus Dunstan John Gulager Pete Jones Patrick Melton Efram Potelle Kyle Rankin Ben Affleck Matt Damon Chris Moore Bravo HBO
TV Review

Project Greenlight (2003)

Project Greenlight | HORROR SHOW Quality versus commerce adds intrigue
Image credit: Project Greenlight: Alan Markfield
HORROR SHOW Quality versus commerce adds intrigue
EW's GRADE
B+

Details Start Dates: Dec 02, 2001, Mar 15, 2005 and Jun 22, 2003; Genre: Reality TV; With: Erica Beeney, Marcus Dunstan, John Gulager, Pete Jones and Patrick Melton...; Networks: Bravo and HBO; More

Art schmart. Ben Affleck and Matt Damon have twice convinced Miramax to pony up several million so that amateurs can create their first indie movie — with the bumpy process documented for their reality series, Project Greenlight. Both seasons produced snoozy coming-of-age films, which were stillborn at the box office. Undaunted, the two have moved their show from an unamused HBO to Bravo, and proclaimed a new goal. ''It's about making a movie that makes a profit,'' Affleck explains.

Almost on cue, this Faustian bargain (can you ensure a quality movie if your primary objective is to earn cash?) blows up in Affleck's and Damon's pretty faces. Miramax's genre wing, Dimension, insists on making the marketable Feast — described by its writers as ''Evil Dead meets Diner'' — despite Damon's deep misgivings about the script: ''Making cynically made, low-budget horror films for the purpose of making a small profit is not the reason I got into Greenlight.''

Mmmmm. . .too bad. Feast gets the nod, and by the end of the premiere, the reality cast is complete: screenwriters Patrick Melton and Marcus Dunstan (who seems trapped in his own bad improv skit) and lumpy, pessimistic director John Gulager, who is easily the most intriguing personality in PG history. Considering PG's integrity-versus-earnings theme, he's the perfect auteur to play off the grabby Dimension execs. (Greenlight was filmed before Miramax's Bob and Harvey Weinstein split with Disney, but the brothers will be involved in the release of Feast.) The insecure Gulager might have a permanent ''Kick me'' sign on his back, but when it comes to movies, he's got the highfalutin outlook that comes from growing up in a filmmaking family. (Greenlight makes the Gulagers seem like home-movie freaks, but John's dad, Clu, wrote and directed the unsettling 1969 cult short A Day With the Boys.)

By the second episode, Gulager is mumbling about the ''integrity and art'' of his favorite director, Fellini, and clashing with the Dimension guys, who want a quick and dirty horror film. The influence of Bravo — which also airs the gawking docuseries Showbiz Moms & Dads — is obvious here. We follow Gulager home as he sits in his bathrobe and talks about his dead mother, and even into the tub where he lolls like a pensive frog. This shy fellow is soon insisting on casting family members in Feast's prime roles and complaining of being disrespected — despite the fact that he refuses to articulate his vision for the film. A box of Goobers says this gets gloriously messy.

Sign up for EW.com's What to Watch Newsletter!

What to watch on TV. Hear what's on tap for the night ahead and get witty, morning after recaps of top shows (sent weekday mornings).
Originally posted Mar 21, 2005 Published in issue #812 Mar 25, 2005 Order article reprints