Birth (2005) When a frowny-faced 10-year-old sneaks into Nicole Kidman's posh apartment in Birth , she reacts the way any normal person would: with calm aloofness. And…
DVD Review

Birth (2005)

EW's GRADE
C-

Details Release Date: Apr 19, 2005; DVD Release Date: Apr 19, 2005; Movie Rated: R; Genres: Mystery and Thriller, Romance; With: Cameron Bright and Nicole Kidman; Distributor: New Line Cinema

When a frowny-faced 10-year-old sneaks into Nicole Kidman's posh apartment in Birth, she reacts the way any normal person would: with calm aloofness. And when he announces that he's actually the reincarnation of her decade-dead husband, why, she becomes even more aloof! That's pretty much what passes for human behavior in this initially absorbing, inevitably absurd mystery, in which we're to believe that the wealthy denizens of Manhattan's upper reaches are so frigid — or maybe so overly Paxilated — that they wouldn't wig out over a creepy kid dredging up painful memories. To overcompensate for the shell-shocked dreariness, director Jonathan Glazer (Sexy Beast) pumps up Alexandre Desplat's taut, lovely score to bombastic degrees and substitutes last-minute plot pileons for revelatory twists. They're distracting gambits that will leave viewers hot and bothered—a state nowhere to be found in Birth's implausibly stuffy setting. EXTRAS None, though perhaps, 10 years down the line, New Line will ''reincarnate'' them on a bonus disc.

Originally posted Apr 18, 2005 Published in issue #816 Apr 22, 2005 Order article reprints