Two EW staffers debate over the latest TV finales | 132225__idol_l
American Idol: Ray Mickshaw

AMERICAN IDOL

He Said ''Hi, I'm Carrie. I'm perfect. I'm pretty. I like country music.'' That's great, but wrong network, sweetie. Take your twang on over to Nashville Star on CMT. Bo Bice is clearly a more talented and exciting Idol candidate. He is a rock star, America. Open your eyes. Okay, well then close them and imagine him with better hair. There. That's your American Idol.

She Said I must have watched her rendition of Heart's ''Alone'' 50 times, so it's no surprise that Carrie triumphed over a mall-haired ''rocker'' with an arrest record and an inability to remove the mic from the stand before picking it up. And since I'm still having trouble coping with America's decision to vote off Constantine, this eases the pain. Mostly.


  • Print
  • Del.icio.us
  • Google
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • More

Copyright © 2008 Entertainment Weekly and Time Inc. All rights reserved.