The Daily Show With Jon Stewart, Jon Stewart, ... | SPIN CITY It's politics as unusual with The Daily Show 's election extravaganza, Indecision 2004
Image credit: The Daily Show: Norman Jean Roy
SPIN CITY It's politics as unusual with The Daily Show's election extravaganza, Indecision 2004
DVD Review

The Daily Show: Indecision 2004 (2005)

EW's GRADE
A-

Details Release Date: Jun 28, 2005; DVD Release Date: Jun 28, 2005

The package claims that the three-disc set includes ''Our National Anthem sung in 4-correspondent harmony.'' As is often the case with this Emmy-winning purveyor of fake news, that statement is even funnier because it's true: That's how The Daily Show began eight tapings covering the Democratic and Republican National Conventions, the main attractions on its first-ever DVD.

You may think Indecision 2004 is too dated for your collection, but the beautiful, or sad, thing about commentary on the spectacle of politics is its timelessness. Come election time, Democrats will always parade their humble roots (see Colbert's historic ''I, the son of a turd miner, the grandson of a goat ball licker'' speech) and the GOP will always excel at negative campaigning (share Stewart's giddiness as he play-by-plays Sen. Zell Miller's RNC verbal assault on John Kerry and MSNBC's Chris Matthews).

The bonus material — which, fortunately, does not include the host's softball interview with Kerry — helps encapsulate the show at its finest. Stewart spin-checks Rudy Giuliani after the first presidential debate, and, on election night, notes that those most affected by 9/11 — New Yorkers — trusted Kerry with their safety. The correspondents flex their trademark wit and shamelessness in field reports like Steve Carell's classic ''Trail and Tribulations,'' when he interviews an unfazed Howard Dean aide while dancing to ''I Got You (I Feel Good).''

Given that the only original extras are a few gag commentaries and Colbert's comedic making-of, ''Requiem for a Show That Was Daily,'' Stewart and Co. clearly still fear being taken seriously. Should we feel guilty for wanting to see how they really work (outside of the restroom)? Pretty sure we'd still be laughing.

Originally posted Jul 01, 2005 Published in issue #828 Jul 08, 2005 Order article reprints

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk * indicates a required field.

500 characters remaining
Advertisement