The Best & Worst of American Idol: Seasons 1-4 (2005) There's no denying the guilty-pleasure appeal of American Idol — but this clip reel of highlights and lowlights underscores how fleeting and watercooler-driven it is.…
DVD Review

The Best & Worst of American Idol: Seasons 1-4 (2005)

OH NO, HE DIDN'T Idol wanna-be, Eric ''Charm'' Berry
Image credit: AMERICAN IDOL:
OH NO, HE DIDN'T Idol wanna-be, Eric ''Charm'' Berry
EW's GRADE
C

Details Release Date: Nov 29, 2005; DVD Release Date: Nov 29, 2005; Movie Rated: Unrated

There's no denying the guilty-pleasure appeal of American Idol — but this clip reel of highlights and lowlights underscores how fleeting and watercooler-driven it is. Okay, it's a little bit fun to revisit Kelly Clarkson's and Clay Aiken's style-challenged beginnings — before the dye job and straightening iron — and to reminisce about Justin Guarini as a heartthrob on the upswing. Beyond that, though, not enough time has passed to make The Best & Worst of American Idol: Seasons 1-4 a nostalgia trip worth taking. And now that William Hung has proven there can be too much of a bad thing, those ap-pawl-ling ''worst of'' auditions should never have resurfaced after serving as the requisite warm-up each season. EXTRAS As for the interview footage, let's just say we'd rather hear the contestants sing than talk. (Clarkson: ''Waitressing isn't the funnest job in the world.'') And Paula's backstage chats with season 4's finalists on their Idol concert tour does nothing for Carrie Underwood & Co.'s street cred. Shocking revelation: They often didn't have time to pray together before the show!

Sign up for EW.com's American Idol Alerts!

Don't miss a story! We'll send you an alert when new American Idol content is added to the site.
Originally posted Nov 25, 2005 Published in issue #852 Dec 02, 2005 Order article reprints