WHAT'S WORKING Katharine's low-key charm and pitch-perfect delivery have drawn comparisons to season 1 champ Kelly Clarkson. Fair enough, considering both ladies tackled risky Aretha covers early in the competition — and pulled them off with panache.
WHAT NEEDS WORK For Katharine, it all comes down to focus. And that means her listless, frumpy alter-ego (the one who limped through ''All in Love Is Fair'') must be permanently banished from the Idol stage.
FROCK U If Katharine's got an Achilles' heel, it's probably her questionable taste in clothing: The dumpy black scoop-neck and rumpled jeans she wore during the March 7 semifinal, for example, should've stayed stuffed in her suitcase.
REQUEST LIST Hank Williams' ''I'm So Lonesome I Could Cry,'' the Motels' ''Only the Lonely,'' 'Til Tuesday's ''Voices Carry''
You Might Also Like
- Movie News Katharine McPhee in 'Storyteller'
- Movie News The latest news from Hollywood
- EW.COM EXCLUSIVE McPhee in Sandler-produced comedy | Nicole Sperling
- NEWS ROUNDUP Kat McPhee making big screen debut | Mike Bruno
