TV Article

Fire Hazard

Is ''Rescue Me'' jumping the shark? Check out today's Ask the Critic question and post your own

Image credit: Rescue Me: Eric Liebowitz

Is ''Rescue Me'' jumping the shark?

Do the recent ''actions'' on Rescue Me qualify as ''jumping the shark''? I don't think so, but the talk going around online tells me otherwise. —Aleks Chan

Let's see, Aleks, do you mean the episode in which Sheila (Callie Thorne) drugged and date-raped Tommy (Denis Leary)? Or the time that Sexy Older Lady (guest star Susan Sarandon) basically stole Franco's daughter — and Franco (Daniel Sunjata) kinda wrote it off, except for a temper tantrum and some wistfulness? I could name a half dozen other oh-come-on! moments in season 3, but I'd actually agree with you. It's less a case of ''jumping the shark'' than ''grabbing shiny object.'' Rescue Me — which I should add I'll never stop watching — can't sit still enough to play out a plotline. Heck, the writers killed off Tommy's son and can't even keep that as a thread. Still, despite my sniping, there are few better ensemble casts on TV: Dean Winters, as Tommy's ex-wife-snatching brother, is a great, cool foil to hothead Leary, and breezy Marisa Tomei should be convinced to join as a regular. Bonus points for giving more screen time to Steven Pasquale, as dim-bulb Sean Garrity. You've got to love anyone who can convincingly court Tatum O'Neal and pull off a sleep-walking scene — which was easily one of the summer's funniest moments.

(Got a TV-related question for Gillian? Post it here.)

Originally posted Aug 03, 2006

From Our Partners