News Article

The 'Sound' and the Fury

Two EW writers share their thoughts on Gwen Stefani's new yodel-stuffed single

Love it or loathe it: ''Wind it Up''

Gwen Stefani's yodel-stuffed single, ''Wind It Up,'' is music to Jeff Jensen's ears — but it really gets Whitney Pastorek's goat

LOVE IT
To be clear, I hate The Sound of Music. It's stupid and boring, and if I ever catch my daughter even humming a note of ''The Lonely Goatherd,'' I'll ship her to a convent. But oh, how I'm tickled by Gwen Stefani's ''Wind It Up,'' another winky and winning collaboration with the Neptunes (''Hollaback Girl''), even with its what the hell? ''Goatherd'' yodeling. Novelty tune? Humbug! The girl just wants to have fun. Better yet, the girl wants to be funny. Can't sexy, fashion-forward dance-music divas have a sense of humor, too? Like her cool 'n' crazy hit, Gwen's got genuine personality. Long may the sound of her madcap music enliven our plastic pop hills. — Jeff Jensen

LOATHE IT
Dealing with the dizzying effect of Gwen ripping off Fergie (who's made a career out of ripping off Gwen) is hard; trying to put this half song into words is damn near impossible. Imagine a cheer-leader being singed with a flatiron while trapped in a pinball machine next to a Sound of Music-themed carousel, and you're close. What hurts the most (besides my ears) is Gwen's decision to chuck her feminist cred by choking out a faux-empowering compost of taunts, grunts, and plugs for her clothing line. I always thought ''Just a Girl'' was ironic...but any more ditzy claptrap like this and I'll have my doubts. — Whitney Pastorek

Originally posted Dec 15, 2006 Published in issue #912 Dec 22, 2006 Order article reprints