Top Chef Unlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox's Hell's Kitchen , on season 3 of Top Chef the food always looks mouthwatering; Judge Tom Colicchio is an… Top Chef Unlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox's Hell's Kitchen , on season 3 of Top Chef the food always looks mouthwatering; Judge Tom Colicchio is an… 2007-06-13
TV Review

Top Chef (2007)

COLICCHIO The Top Chef judge is ''an exemplary combination of talent, constructiveness, and high standards''
Image credit: Carin Baer
COLICCHIO The Top Chef judge is ''an exemplary combination of talent, constructiveness, and high standards''
EW's GRADE
A-

Details Start Date: Jun 13, 2007; More

Unlike the drill-sergeant antics on Fox's Hell's Kitchen, on season 3 of Top Chef the food always looks mouthwatering; Judge Tom Colicchio is an exemplary combination of talent, constructiveness, and high standards; and not a morsel of entertainment value is wasted. Like most Bravo competition shows, Top Chef proceeds from the premise that there is fun in putting a group of exceptionally skilled and ambitious people together and pushing them to do their best. It might not sound like much fun to eavesdrop on a bunch of talented prima donnas throwing down over sloppy knife work and the deployment of flavored foams, but it's much more exciting (and appetite-whetting) than the Hell's Kitchen alternative of watching a bunch of doofuses get reamed for burning the rice. The food looks better on Top Chef, and so does the production; there isn't nearly as much TV-for-dummies editing as on Hell's Kitchen — you know, in case your mind wandered during the commercial, here's a whole minute that you just saw again. That's filler — TV's version of Hamburger Helper. And real cooking shows don't use it. In my dream reality series, the best of Top Chef's contestants would go burner to burner with Ramsay. I suspect they'd make sushi out of him. And still make it look good enough to eat. A-

Sign up for EW.com's What to Watch Newsletter!

What to watch on TV. Hear what's on tap for the night ahead and get witty, morning after recaps of top shows (sent weekday mornings).
Originally posted Aug 03, 2007 Published in issue #947 Aug 10, 2007 Order article reprints
Advertisement

From Our Partners