Book Review

Spiced (2009)

EW's GRADE
B-

Details Release Date: Apr 16, 2009; Writer: Dalia Jurgensen; Genres: Memoir, Nonfiction; Publisher: Putnam

Dalia Jurgensen, ''eager to 
 escape the small office'' after working in publishing, went 
to culinary school, got a job as a pastry chef at a fancy New York restaurant, and writes about her experiences in Spiced. Katherine Darling, ready to leave ''the safety of the office environment'' after working at a literary agency, went to a fancy New York culinary school 
and writes about her experiences in Under the Table. 
Simon Majumdar, tired of ''arguments over budgets'' after working in, yes, book publishing, consumed a 
lot of food around the world and writes about his 
experiences in Eat My Globe.

All three books are undercooked. All three are 
written in Cheez Whiz prose not nearly as interesting as the raw ingredients of the stories. For that I blame 
Anthony Bourdain and Top Chef. Bourdain, after all, wrote the tasty tell-all Kitchen Confidential about what goes on behind the swinging doors separating restaurant diners from their food — and made dishing about dishes look easy. Top Chef suggests that the most successful chefs are those who promote their colorful personalities along with their knife skills.

So here's Jurgensen, who serves up tidbits about 
the celebrity diners at her restaurant and about a lesbian fling and a longer relationship with a studly chef, but who can't find words other than ''we were all insanely 
different people'' to describe her co-workers. Here's 
Darling, who offers the glib, condescending insight that ''chicken breasts come from chickens, not from Styrofoam trays in the grocery store.'' And here, ye gods of M.F.K. Fisher, is the British-born Majumdar, piling on metaphors like fake grill marks on a hunk of inferior steak. Imagining his reaction were he to meet a certain idolized chef, he warns, ''I would probably faint like a bobby-soxer at a Fabian concert.''

They don't have to pack away their knives, but for now these three memoirists ought to sharpen their narrative skills. Spiced: B– Under the Table: C+ Eat My Globe: C–

Originally posted Apr 15, 2009 Published in issue #1044-1045 Apr 24, 2009 Order article reprints

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk * indicates a required field.

500 characters remaining
Advertisement