EW's Special Coverage

Charlie Sheen Central

TV Article

Laugh Track

Which sitcoms have lost their humor? Ken Tucker rates six network mainstays, including ''Everybody Loves Raymond'' and ''Friends''

Ray Romano, Patricia Heaton, ... | OR DO THEY? Is ''everybody'' an exaggeration?
Image credit: Everybody Loves Raymond: Robert Voets/CBS
OR DO THEY? Is ''everybody'' an exaggeration?

Which sitcoms have lost their humor?

Does anyone talk about their favorite sitcoms anymore? Between reality-TV overload and ongoing debates about one-hour dramas -- you defend ''West Wing,'' I'm starting to get addicted to ''Without a Trace'' -- the sitcom format seems more ignored than ever. So let's revive the genre: I'll do a quick rundown of a half-dozen laffers that run from fab to blechhh, and you chime in with your opinions. But before we begin: START WATCHING ''ANDY RICHTER CONTROLS THE UNIVERSE,'' YOU SILLIES! Here we go:

''Friends'' They're back for another year, but I'm not feelin' the love for this season's so-so, baby's-here run of episodes -- are you? The performances are fine, jokes are solid, but ''Friends'' is lacking that something extra, like last season's unexpected expansion of Joey's role. B

''Everybody Loves Raymond'' It's constantly near or at the top of the ratings chart, so am I alone in thinking this show has become an uncomfortable viewing experience? The Barone clan's neuroses and inter-irritations have turned them kinda sour and mean. But still pretty funny; it's just that wincing is not a reaction I associate with amusement. B-

''Frasier'' When Niles went under the knife earlier this season, it confirmed the suspicion that the writers had run out of comedic plots and were now relying on heartstring-tugging. Leave my heart alone, ''Frasier'' scribes! I want more heartlessly humorous badinage between Frasier and a healthy, snippy Niles! C+

''Girlfriends'' I've been watching the UPN's only decent sitcom for its snappy byplay and for its welcome view of black women as people other than jive-talking clichés. But what the producers needed to do this season was move these galpals into new situations in which their social circle could expand; otherwise, the patter turns into shtick. Or jive. B-

''Just Shoot Me'' This show is still on? D-

''Becker'' Sorry, I know Ted Danson is giving a good performance every week, and he's successfully created a fresh sitcom persona post-''Cheers,'' an almost unheard-of achievement for anyone except Bob Newhart and... well, the post-''Cheers'' Kelsey Grammer. But ''Becker'' is just a flat little thing, airless and drab. C

So what sitcoms are your favorites or your LEAST favorite?

Originally posted Jan 06, 2003