A Joyful Noise Two albums after their 2006 breakout Standing in the Way of Control , the once-scrappy trio are still trying on different post-fame hats, often in… A Joyful Noise Two albums after their 2006 breakout Standing in the Way of Control , the once-scrappy trio are still trying on different post-fame hats, often in… Gossip Rock Columbia
Music Review

A Joyful Noise

MESSY GOSSIP 'Noise' proves to be is an inconsistent effort from the dance rock trio
Image credit: Rankin
MESSY GOSSIP 'Noise' proves to be is an inconsistent effort from the dance rock trio
EW's GRADE
B-

Details Lead Performance: Gossip; Genre: Rock; Production: Columbia

Two albums after their 2006 breakout Standing in the Way of Control, the once-scrappy trio are still trying on different post-fame hats, often in the same song. Do they want to be highbrow purveyors of danceable angst, or pensive chroniclers of punk anomie? It helps that they've still got Beth Ditto's clarion voice and her bandmates' jittery, White Stripes-ian riffs while they're figuring it out — and that the album has bursts of riot-disco alchemy (like ''Move in the Right Direction''). But without a clear purpose, most of A Joyful Noise blends into a fog of wandering melodies and come-and-go beats that sound ambivalent about even wanting your attention. B-

Best Tracks:
Breakup boogie Move in the Right Direction
It's-not-love ballad Involved
Originally posted May 16, 2012 Published in issue #1208 May 25, 2012 Order article reprints
Advertisement

Today's Most Popular

  1. Photo Gallery: American Music Awards 2014 American Music Awards '14: We grade the performances
  2. Photo Gallery: American Music Awards 2014 American Music Awards 2014 style: What the stars wore

From Our Partners