Though it opened to stronger business in New York City than in six California burgs — which goes to show that mean movies play best on mean streets — viewers on both coasts (more than half of them women) had plenty to say about In the Company of Men:

GAYLE, 33, handbag product developer, Venice: ''The main guy was a sicko. I just kept thinking, Karma, karma, karma.''

ELAINE, 29, consultant, NYC: ''It was more antimale than it was misogynist. They were depicted as totally evil. No one is actually that evil.''

GREG, 25, real estate agent, Los Angeles: ''It's exaggerated and unrealistic. I don't know too many guys like Chad.''

ELIZABETH, 37, theater professor, NYC: ''I don't think this is so shocking. Carnal Knowledge deals with the same issues and it's actually a little more shocking.''

HEIDI, 33, waitress, West Hollywood: ''I've never met any [men]like that. Or maybe I have. That's a scary thought.''

BRIAN, 30, film producer, NYC: ''I was shocked to see that the crowd was 50-60 percent women, because most of the women I know have left somewhat repulsed by it. But...it's still more interesting to the average woman than, say, Liar Liar.''

— Additional reporting by Allison Gaines and Carrie Bell


Sign up for EW.com's The 25 newsletter!

Stay in the know and get EW.com's top 5 stories, 5 days a week (sent weekday afternoons).