Music Review

Baroque Duet (1992)

EW's GRADE
C

Details Lead Performances: Kathleen Battle, Wynton Marsalis and The Orchestra of St. Luke's; Genre: Classical

If there is a more beguiling noise on earth than the sound of Kathleen Battle's singing, it could be the plangent blare of Wynton Marsalis' trumpet. Inevitably, the meeting of these two blithe spirits should result in a kind of sonic epiphany, with Marsalis making the easy crossover from his jazzman's world to sit in on a clutch of 17th- and 18th-century arias for soprano and brass obbligato, and Battle scaling the vocal peaks of this daunting repertory with feathery ease. But such stirring, striding music as Handel's ''Let the Bright Seraphim'' and Alessandro Scarlatti's ''Su le sponde del Tebro'' come off in Battle's versions merely as studies in pretty singing devoid of any stylistic identity. Battle hits the high notes with awesome accuracy, but the music itself lies out of her reach. On Baroque Duet, what little stylistic sense surfaces from this virtuoso pairing comes out of the 24-karat elegance of Marsalis' golden trumpet. C

Originally posted Jun 19, 1992 Published in issue #123 Jun 19, 1992 Order article reprints
You Might Also Like

Add your comment

The rules: Keep it clean, and stay on the subject or we might delete your comment. If you see inappropriate language, e-mail us. An asterisk * indicates a required field.

500 characters remaining
Advertisement