American Masters -- Frederic Remington: "The Truth of Other Days" (1991) Here's an unusual instance in which this series must prove that its subject is an American master. Frederic Remington (1861- 1909) was and remains an… Documentary Gregory Peck PBS
TV Review

American Masters -- Frederic Remington: ''The Truth of Other Days'' (1991)

EW's GRADE
B

Details Genre: Documentary; With: Gregory Peck; Network: PBS

Here's an unusual instance in which this series must prove that its subject is an American master. Frederic Remington (1861- 1909) was and remains an exceptionally popular artist, known for his realistically detailed canvases of life in the Old West, but as narrator Gregory Peck asks, ''Was he a mere illustrator or a great painter?''

Watching the documentary The Truth of Other Days, you'd have to conclude that Remington was a combination of Peck's choices: a great illustrator. We see lots of the heroic, unabashedly sentimental pictures of cowboys and Indians Remington painted for magazines like Collier's and Harper's Weekly. Brian Dippie, a professor at Canada's University of Victoria, notes, ''He gave editors exactly what they wanted: fresh material and a fresh way of looking at it'' — not exactly a description of a groundbreaking artist.

Ultimately, Remington's work comes across as first-rate pulp entertainment, and this lively hour includes a terrific sequence that demonstrates the way many scenes in John Ford's classic 1949 Western, She Wore a Yellow Ribbon, echo images in particular Remington paintings. B

Sign up for EW.com's What to Watch Newsletter!

What to watch on TV. Hear what's on tap for the night ahead and get witty, morning after recaps of top shows (sent weekday mornings).
Originally posted Aug 02, 1991 Published in issue #77 Aug 02, 1991 Order article reprints