Double Takes

Image credit: Justin Guarini: Fox

All About

American Idol

Get the latest photos, news, and more

Justin Guarini
Singing ''Get Here,'' one of the original songs that landed him in the finals of the competition, Justin perfected his crooning, romantic voice and even impressed those of us who'd already heard him sing this one. Randy called it ''the best performance in this whole competition,'' and Simon said it was ''a great song, fantastically delivered.'' A

For some reason, Justin is cursed with a near inability to pick good songs. Why he chose to do an almost lyric-free ''PYT'' was beyond the judges. Randy said it was ''just all right,'' but Simon dissed him with ''it was a bad impersonation of Michael Jackson.'' At least Paula pulled out a compliment, insincere as it was, when she mumbled ''great job.'' C+